Listening to Voice Hearers viewing notes

Listening to Voice Hearers, Viewing Notes

Listening to Voice Hearers features Kate Crawford, Bob Green and Shaun Hunt.

Filmed and edited by Bob Sapey

 

https://youtu.be/LNAuckNrC34

 

This film features three people who have heard voices for most of their lives and still do. Kate, Bob and Shaun all work with Peter Bullimore as part of the Sheffield Hearing Voices Network and the National Paranoia Network. As part of this work they talk publicly about their experiences of voice hearing, of psychosis and of the psychiatric system. They do this in order to demonstrate that their voices cannot be simply explained as a negative symptom of illnesses such as schizophrenia or bi-polar disorder, but that they are emotional responses to traumatic life experiences.

In 2014 I was privileged to be able to interview Kate, Bob and Shaun. The interviews were semi-structured, I wanted to ask them about four main aspects of their experiences of hearing voices:

  • History of when voices entered their lives;
  • What the voices say;
  • Origin of voices; and
  • Childhood experiences.

These were based upon some of the categories in the Maastricht Interview and it might be helpful to bear these in mind when viewing the film. A good account of the Interview can be found in a paper by Dirk Corstens, Sandra Escher and Marius Romme, the people who developed the Maastricht Approach, http://www.dirkcorstens.com/maastrichtapproach/.

In editing the recordings I had made, I wanted to retain the authenticity of individual narratives, but also show the ways in which their experiences might be shared. As a result this film is not edited to make viewing easy, so do be prepared to listen for a full hour.

The following notes may also be useful as a means of finding your way back to particular parts at a later date. I hope you find these notes and the film informative and interesting.

Bob Sapey, 7th November 2015

 

Introductory Narration

0.00-2.45

For as long as people have heard voices there have been differences of opinion as to their nature and cause.

There have been spiritual explanations in which people may claim to be hearing the voices of gods and angels and maybe the voices of the devil and other bad spirits.

This has often led people into conflict with the leaders of organised religions, who have felt threatened by such direct relationships with their gods.

There have also been medical explanations and since the late 19th century these have focused on the brain. Throughout the 20th century the idea that voices are caused by mental illnesses, particularly by schizophrenia, has come to dominate medical knowledge. In this view, voices are auditory hallucinations that need to be suppressed with anti psychotic medication.

However, since the late 1970s another idea has found much favour with people who hear voices, that their voices are a psychological response to life experiences, particularly childhood trauma.

In this approach, people try to understand the meaning of their voices and then negotiate ways of living with them.

This approach has become quite influential and in December 2014 the British Psychological Society said that,

Hearing voices or feeling paranoid are common experiences which can often be a reaction to trauma, abuse or deprivation. Calling them symptoms of mental illness, psychosis or schizophrenia is only one way of thinking about them, with advantages and disadvantages.[1]

Gail Hornstein, an American psychologist who describes herself as being ‘as interested in patients’ experiences as in doctors’ theories’ has said that,

We are now living at a time when there is a systematic alternative to understanding madness and treatment based entirely on first hand experiences. It offers a powerful challenge to our taken-for-granted ideas and has the potential to be more successful than traditional approaches in helping people to cope with psychotic experiences.[2]

As a person who has never heard voices, I was interested to learn more so I spoke with Kate, Bob and Shaun, all of whom have long experiences of voice hearing. In this film they each talk about their experiences of hearing voices, the reasons for their voices and the ways in which they have learned to live with them.

Part One

2.46-8.52

This part of the film starts with Kate describing her voices and her beliefs about where they come from. Her voices started as helpful until about the age of 7, but then became threatening. Kate describes the way her voices increased in number to hundreds and then thousands. She associates the increase in the numbers and nastiness of the voices with punishments and abuse she experienced as a child and teenager.

8.54-15.20

Next Bob describes how his voices started as an imaginary friend in childhood. Again he associates this to sexual abuse he experienced as a child. Bob describes how talking about his voices in the Hearing Voices Network has recently helped him to deal with his voices. Bob describes how the HVN group has helped him so much more than any medicines he has taken. He talks of losing 15 years of his life through being subdued by medication.

15.21-23.38

Shaun talks about how he cannot control his internal voice as he might control his thoughts. He has heard voices since childhood.  At first they were just commenting on what he was doing and made him feel protected. Later, following abuse by his father, the content of the voices changed and they became more aggressive. Sometimes he finds his voices amusing and entertaining. Shaun describes his ‘grizzly’ voice which is very loud and controlling.

Interlude

 

Part Two

24.11-30.54

Kate describes her experiences of abuse by her mother, her grandmother, bullying by children at school and the way her voices are related to this. She describes the way teachers and other adults failed to ever listen to her. Despite considerable abuse, Kate describes herself as lucky to only be hearing voices compared to her cousin who was brain damaged by abuse.

30.55-34.36

In addition to being abused as a child, Bob describes how at the age of 15, witnessing an ice-cream van running over a child’s head led to an increase in his voices. He was unable to talk to his parents about his voices or his abuse. Bob describes how as an adult, talking to his voices led to people thinking badly of him.

34.37-38.44

Shaun thinks his voices may have started as a form of protection when he was being abused. He feels that the softest voice has characteristics of his grandad. He thinks his voices reflect his emotions. He thinks his voices are not a problem, rather his reaction to them can be.

38.45-44.07

Kate describes other people’s responses to her when she tells them about hearing voices. She talks about doctors, police and nurses as lacking any appreciation of what she was experiencing and sometimes denying that her experiences are real. This resulted several times in her being compulsorily detained and forcibly medicated.

44.08-48.26

Shaun talks about his experience of psychiatric services and how, because he is 6 foot 3 and diagnosed as having schizophrenia, he has been viewed as dangerous, forcibly medicated and detained in a forensic unit at the request of the police.  Shaun now feels that hearing voices is a positive experience and that instead of trying to eradicate the voices, psychiatric services could help people to learn more about them.

48.27-51.24

Bob has a much more negative experience of hearing voices and talking about them in the HVN group has helped him a lot. He doesn’t think the psychiatric professionals understand what voice hearers are going through and they could learn a lot from the HVN group. Bob is preparing to talk about his experiences to a large group at a conference.

51.26-51.54

Shaun introduces himself to the Paranoia Network conference at Manchester in 2014.

51.55-57.16

Kate explains why she is prepared to talk about her abuse and her voices in order to give others hope, rather than them being left with the idea that they have an incurable disease. She goes on to describe how she has been able to help others.



[1] Executive Summary of Understanding Psychosis and Schizophrenia, edited by Anna Cooke and published in 2014 by the British Psychological Society

[2] From her speech at the mhhe conference at Lancaster University, Living and Learning: Learning and Teaching: Mental Health in Higher Education, 30-31 March 2010.

Views: 182

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Mental Health in Higher Education Hub to add comments!

Join Mental Health in Higher Education Hub

Blog Posts

Humanising health and social care - some links

Posted by Jill Anderson on November 5, 2018 at 14:29 0 Comments

Some links to project with a focus on the mental health of mental health professionals and/or humanising health and social care. 

Action for Careforce Wellbeing

https://survivingwork.org/action-for-care-worker-wellbeing/

In2gr8mentalhealth

Destigmatising the experience of mental ill-health in mental health professionals…

Continue

Keeping Control - animation

Posted by Jill Anderson on November 3, 2018 at 10:10 0 Comments

This animation was commissioned to disseminate the findings from a research project carried out at Middlesex University.Keeping control

The project set out to address an important gap in research and practice knowledge relating to ‘disability hate crime’, targeted violence and hostility against people with mental health…

Continue

Alternatives to Coercion in Mental Health Settings - Literature Review

Posted by Jill Anderson on November 3, 2018 at 10:00 0 Comments

A Melbourne Social Equity Institute research team is examining ways of avoiding coercive practices to ensure people experiencing mental health crises are treated with dignity and respect.  Most recently, the team undertook a systematic review of global practices that aim to reduce, prevent and end…

Continue

Kindness, Emotions and Human Relationships - the blind spot in public policy: new report

Posted by Jill Anderson on November 3, 2018 at 10:00 0 Comments

There is growing recognition of the importance of kindness and relationships for societal wellbeing. But talking about kindness does not fit easily within the rational lexicon of public policy. 

Julia Unwin’s report, for the Carnegie Trust, Kindness, emotions and human…

Continue

Journal of autoethnography for health and social care.

Posted by Jill Anderson on October 17, 2018 at 17:32 0 Comments

This journal aims to provide a forum for opening intellectual curiousity and exploration via auto ethnographic enquiry. The journal casts a critical eye over the material, social, cultural and political worlds we inhabit.

Find out more.

Keeping Control - animation

Posted by Jill Anderson on October 12, 2018 at 11:00 0 Comments

IF BAD THINGS HAPPEN AND THEN YOU ARE NOT HELPED OR PROTECTED THAT MAKES IT MUCH WORSE

This animation was commissioned to disseminate the findings from a research project carried out at Middlesex…

Continue

Action for Care Workers' Wellbeing

Posted by Jill Anderson on October 12, 2018 at 10:30 1 Comment

Yesterday, on World Mental Health Day (10 October 2018), Action for Care-Workers Wellbeing (ACW) was launched.

Facilitated by BASW, ACW is a collaborative network of professionals from the NHS and social care who represent a wide range of key UK caring professions (Nursing, General Practice, Psychiatry, Psychology, Social Work and Paramedics).

The group’s aim is to raise awareness of stress and burnout within the health and social care workforce, identify solutions, and propose…

Continue

Abstracts and reviewers wanted: International Conference on Social Work in Health and Mental Health

Posted by Jill Anderson on October 5, 2018 at 10:14 0 Comments

The 9th International Conference on Social Work in Health and Mental Health takes place in York next July. It is an opportunity for social work practitioners, researchers, service users and carers to come together to discuss practice innovations, research and futures for social work in the spheres of health and…
Continue

Upcoming changes to the Mental Health and Mental Capacity Acts: video of SCIE webinar

Posted by Jill Anderson on September 27, 2018 at 15:17 0 Comments

In September 2018, SCIE hosted a webinar to discuss the forthcoming changes to the Mental Health Act and the Mental Capacity Act. The webinar reflected on the important changes in how people's rights are protected. A panel of policy and practice experts in both pieces of legislation helped practitioners, academics and others reflect on these important changes.

View…

Continue

Minds, Madness, Medicine: should we change the way we treat mental illnesses? - video of debate at the Hay festival

Posted by Jill Anderson on September 23, 2018 at 7:42 0 Comments

Deaths from heart disease have fallen by almost two thirds since the 1960s.Yet outcomes for those with mental illness, from depression and anxiety to schizophrenia and bipolar disorders, have not improved for decades. Is this because we have the wrong diagnoses? Might neuroscience provide more precise descriptions and therefore more effective treatment? Or is mental health too complex for us to understand it in mere…

Continue

© 2018   Created by Jill Anderson.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service