Teaching critical approaches to depression and anxiety when you are depressed and anxious - by Jane EM Callaghan

New blog bost by Jane EM Callaghan: 

"In the many years I have taught mental health, I have always wrestled with a fundamental contradiction. On the one hand, I have a political commitment to an anti-diagnostic, and anti-medicalisation stance. On the other hand, I have struggled life long with anxiety, trauma responses, and depression.

This year, I came to teach my classes on anxiety and depression 9 months into my treatment with duloxetine. This has been a life saving drug for me. It has relieved my anxiety very significantly, I can sleep better at night, and I can function without constant ruminative thoughts during the day.  It is also probably slowly eroding my liver function, but hey, swings and roundabouts, right?

So how do I handle this reality, when teaching my students to be appropriately skeptical about the claims of pharmaceutical companies, and to be concerned about the validity of certain diagnoses?......"

Read more

Views: 34

Comment by Bob Sapey on April 8, 2017 at 8:59
Very interesting blog.
Comment by Simon Rose on April 25, 2017 at 17:01

Really interesting article

Am wondering if there is also something in the fact that medication can be started immediately whilst there are often significant waiting lists for anything other than the simplistic IAPT 6-8 weeks of CBT. In the area that I live and work, waiting lists of 1-2 years are the norm for more involved forms of therapy. Todays society puts so much pressure on people to 'get cured' and go back to being a productive human being (worker, carer, parent etc.), that the idea of having to wait so long is difficult - plus, of course, living in emotional pain waiting for therapy to start is not something that anyone would relish.

But, medication, for lots of us, does little more than paper over the cracks. Accepting Eleanor Longdon's argument that a good starting point for a psychiatric 'history' is not 'what has happened to you?' rather than 'what is wrong with you'?, over reliance on medication looks problematic. The core reasons behind the emotional and mental distress are never resolved - we are chemically 'modified' to be able to live with the symptoms that stem from whatever has caused the problems in the first place.

I write this from the perspective of someone that has taken meds for 20 odd years, been hospitalised numerous times who now works alongside undergrad medical students helping to get lived experience into their learning when on psychiatry placement. I have had spells of psychological intervention, but not enough to overcome the damage that occurred through childhood. Meds help me keep a lid on my emotions most of the time. For that, I am thankful. Problem is that I cannot actually see a time when I would be comfortable to come off them

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Mental Health in Higher Education Hub to add comments!

Join Mental Health in Higher Education Hub

Blog Posts

Integrating mental health and social care - does it work in practice?

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 24, 2018 at 10:55 0 Comments

In the second of the Centre for Mental Health’s series We need to talk about social care, Kim Woodbridge-Dodd looks at the integration of mental health and social care,  the benefits behind this and the challenges faced on the ground.

Find out more.…

Continue

#socialcarefuture

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 24, 2018 at 10:50 0 Comments



#socialcarefuture is an initiative – voluntarily organised – which aims to bring about major positive change in what is currently called “social care”. Those involved will be citizens, people using public services and their families, workers and professionals, managers and politicians. #socialcarefuture is being steered by an informal group and is open to involvement from others wanting to offer ideas, skills and…

Continue

Beyond Closed Doors:

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 22, 2018 at 13:30 0 Comments

An exploration of UK alternatives to psychiatric hospitalisation for people in Mental Health Crisis. Filmed in 2002 by Bryony Rogers. 

View the film…

Continue

A new vision for mental health

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 21, 2018 at 15:55 0 Comments

‘Have you ever wondered what mental healthcare would look like if, knowing what we know today, it could be redesigned from scratch? A New Vision for Mental Health is an innovative website that seeks to answer this question by taking a critical, informed and constructive look at the current mental health system. It explores ideas, insights and suggestions – from a wide range of individuals and organisations – that might, in time, lay the foundations for a new and quite different approach to…

Continue

Maintaining momentum: driving improvements in mental health care - new report

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 21, 2018 at 15:54 0 Comments

'Maintaining momentum' highlights failings in specialist mental health services in England, and the devastating toll this takes on patients and their families. 

The report's findings provide fresh impetus to deliver on the recommendations set out in the NHS Five Year Forward View for Mental Health.

Download here…

Continue

Russel Razzaque talk on breakdown and spirituality

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 19, 2018 at 12:40 0 Comments

Dr. Russell Razzaque is a London-based psychiatrist with sixteen years’ experience in adult mental health. He is the author of Breaking Down is Waking Up. He has worked for a number of national and international organisations during his career including the University of Cambridge, the UK Home Office and the Ministry of Justice. He currently works in acute mental health services in the NHS in East London. He is also a published author in human psychology with several books on the subject and…

Continue

Contribute to Asylum magazine

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 19, 2018 at 12:33 0 Comments

The latest issue of Asylum magazine is out now.

There are a number of ways in which you can contribute to Asylum:

  • Subscribe to Asylum – print and digital versions of the magazine are available.
  • Order bulk copies and distribute them.
  • Set up or join a local…
Continue

Health Inequalities Manifesto 2018

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 19, 2018 at 12:26 0 Comments

People living in the least deprived areas of England live around 20 years longer in good physical and mental health than people in the most deprived areas.

Tackling and reducing health inequalities means giving everyone the same opportunities to lead a mentally and physically healthy life, no matter where they live and who they are.

Certain population subgroups are at higher risk of mental health problems because of greater exposure and vulnerability to…

Continue

With children in mind: call for papers

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 19, 2018 at 12:20 0 Comments

This issue of the Journal of Public Mental Health will, specifically, cover the promotion of mental health and emotional wellbeing and the prevention of mental ill health and crises in children and young people. Manuscripts are sought that discuss the role of parents, carers, teachers and health care staff in the promotion of good mental health, including resilience and wellbeing.…

Continue

Projects of the Self A Being-Human funded research project into resilience, grit, and self-efficacy narratives in Higher Education

Posted by Jill Anderson on March 17, 2018 at 20:38 0 Comments

This project was set up as a result of concern with the growing neoliberalisation of higher education, and to explore the widespread adoption of approaches informed by notions such as grit, resilience, and the Growth Mindset.

Find out more.

© 2018   Created by Jill Anderson.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service